train wheels

Train Wheels are Not as Simple as They Seem

By Anupum Pant

I’m pretty sure not many of you know this about train wheels, neither did I.

Look at the picture and answer this: What do you think keeps a train moving on the track? or Which part of the wheel do you think it is that keeps the train from careening away from the track at turns?
Applying general logic, I thought that flanges at the end of the wheels  kept a train from going off rails at a turn. Turns out, I was wrong!

In fact, flanges at the end of the wheels are just a safety mechanism to keep the train on its track only if the main mechanism fails. And what is that main mechanism?

The problem with cornersTrain wheels are conical in shape. That means they have a varying diameter at different points of contact. Now, suppose the track turns right. The train’s left wheels now have to travel more than the right wheels because at the turn the track on the left is longer.

So how do the left wheels travels more than the right wheels without a differential?
Since the wheels are conical in shape, the whole wheel-set shifts a bit to the left, if the track curves right. Now the point of contact of the left wheel is at a larger diameter of the cone. While the smaller wheel Correction from the toptouches at a point where the diameter of the wheel is lesser. Therefore, if the left wheel now makes one circle it travels further than the right wheels and the train moves along the curve smoothly.

The whole beauty of this system is that the amount of shift of the wheel-set happens automatically, makes the train move on turns smoothly and keeps the train on track.

Look at how you can try this at home using 2 plastic cups and 2 similar pipes. [Experiment]

If I couldn’t explain it properly, probably the best physics teacher ever – Richard Feynman – will explain it to you better. [Video]

Enhanced by Zemanta

5 thoughts on “Train Wheels are Not as Simple as They Seem”

  1. On reflection, I respectfully disagree–even with Dr. Feynman.

    The answer provided is the correct answer, but to the wrong question. They answered the question: What keeps the wheel on a train from wearing out prematurely. The answer is the very clever conical shape of the wheels which allow the outside wheels to turn faster than the inside wheels.

    The answer to the question posed is clearly: the flanges keep the train on the track. The flanges are not a safety device in case the other device (conical shape) fails; they are the only thing that keeps the train on the track. With uneven track, bounces and curves, the wheels would slide off the track, even on straight runs, but for, the flanges.

    1. The shape of the wheels also keeps the train on the track. In a straight run if the train starts to go more to the right, the wheel that is on the right side will make contact on the track with the longer diameter of the wheel while the left wheel will have a shorter diameter, making it turn slightly to the left; and making it go straight again.

  2. But the question arrives that train’s wheel and the rails, both are plain then how does it accelerate without sleeping?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *